Trade Help!!

Post Reply  
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
I'm in a Keeper league (PPR) and have been offered a trade, I need your help.
My 5 Keepers are: A.Foster, A.Peterson, C.Johnson, D.Murray and A.Johnson

I would give away one of my 4 RBs

For

Eli Manning and 1st Rd Pick/#5

I'm leaning towards not doing it, simply because I can find a QB in the draft but RBs are hard to come by. What do y'all think?
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 2556
Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2010
Sand$: 47,231.34
I would hang on to your RB's.
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 19265
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2008
Sand$: 71,852.40
I would like to see your starting reqs, Im not in the group that you should be keeping all 4 rbs depending on your reqs. I dont think I take that trade , but I would be looking for another one.
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
Here's my roster, I get to keep 5.
QB: M.Vick, T.Romo
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, C.Johnson, D.Muarry, M.Bush, C.J. Spiller
WR: A. Johnson, J.Jones (ATL), D.Bryant, M.Colston
TE: J.Finley
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers
Megalodon
Posts: 10802
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007
Sand$: 42,808.66
I would not do this specific trade. You already have Vick who approximates Eli at worst. I would not trade an RB1 for essentially a 6th round pick,
_______________________________________

The Raiders new solar system to power up their offense: DC to AC.
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 19265
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2008
Sand$: 71,852.40
annapolis_4 wrote:Here's my roster, I get to keep 5.
QB: M.Vick, T.Romo
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, C.Johnson, D.Muarry, M.Bush, C.J. Spiller
WR: A. Johnson, J.Jones (ATL), D.Bryant, M.Colston
TE: J.Finley



Unless you can start all 4 rbs, i would be looking to move murray for a wr or a pick and keep either romo or vick. Romo being the safer keeper Vick being the higher risk/reward player.

or trade one of your 2 qbs and murray for a rodgers
Chum
Posts: 21
Joined: Sat Apr 7, 2012
Sand$: 58.00
I think you are going to be sick for not taking Dez!!! Personally I would keep AJ, Dez, Foster, Chris Johnson, and Murray. What pick do you have in the first round?
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 1808
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005
Sand$: 2,544.08
QB: M.Vick, T.Romo
WR: A.Johnson, D.Bryant, J.Jones (ATL), M.Colston
RB: A.Peterson, C.Johnson(4.24), A.Foster(Hou), D.Murray, M.Bush, C.J Spiller
TE: J.Finley

I would keep Julio, Dez, CJ, Foster and Murray

and I would absolutely NOT make that trade.
_______________________________________

"The wisest men follow their own direction
And listen to no prophet guiding them.
None but the fools believe in oracles,
Forsaking their own judgment. Those who know,
Know that such men can only come to grief." - Euripides, 414 BC
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 1808
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005
Sand$: 2,544.08
:guns:
_______________________________________

"The wisest men follow their own direction
And listen to no prophet guiding them.
None but the fools believe in oracles,
Forsaking their own judgment. Those who know,
Know that such men can only come to grief." - Euripides, 414 BC
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
Thanks so much for the input, I greatly appreciate it.
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers
Megalodon
Posts: 10802
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007
Sand$: 42,808.66
how many qbs/rbs/wr can you start?

Unless you have to start 2 QBs, I would not keep a QB over your RBs/WRs.

Foster is a no brainer. I would try to keep only 3 RBs if you cannot start 4. Would also keep Julio over Bryant. If you can keep your keepers indefinitely, then I would prioritize Julio over AJ as well.
_______________________________________

The Raiders new solar system to power up their offense: DC to AC.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests