Trade: Good or Bad? Opinions Please

Post Reply  
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
I'm in a 10 team keeper league (PPR). I just made a trade and would like y'all opinion on it. Keep in mind, I already have the 1.1 pick in the draft.
These were my 4 Keepers: A. Foster, A. Peterson, C. Johnson and A. Johnson

I traded away:
Chris Johnson and 3.6 pick

FOR

1.3 pick and 2.4 pick

So, now I have the 1.1, 1.3, 2.4 and 2.5 pick in the draft.

Players Available:
QB: M. Stafford, T. Romo, M. Vick, J. Freeman, P. Manning, B. Rothelis, RG3, A. Luck, A. Dalton, J. Cutler, J. Flacco
RB: J. Charles, T. Richardson, A. Bradshaw, S. Jax, B. Wells, D. Sporles, S. Greene, R. Helu, D. Martin, J. Stewart
WR: P. Harvin, V. Jackson, M. Wallace, M. Colston, J. Jones (ATL), D. Thomas (DEN), D. Bryant, M. Austin, K. Britt, E. Decker, B. Lloyd, D. Bowe, P. Garcon, A. Brown.

Good trade or not??!?!!?!??! I figured I could let C.Johnson go because I still have A.Foster and A.Peterson.
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers
Megalodon
Posts: 10802
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007
Sand$: 42,808.66
annapolis_4 wrote:I'm in a 10 team keeper league (PPR). I just made a trade and would like y'all opinion on it. Keep in mind, I already have the 1.1 pick in the draft.
These were my 4 Keepers: A. Foster, A. Peterson, C. Johnson and A. Johnson

I traded away:
Chris Johnson and 3.6 pick

FOR

1.3 pick and 2.4 pick

So, now I have the 1.1, 1.3, 2.4 and 2.5 pick in the draft.

Players Available:
QB: M. Stafford, T. Romo, M. Vick, J. Freeman, P. Manning, B. Rothelis, RG3, A. Luck, A. Dalton, J. Cutler, J. Flacco
RB: J. Charles, T. Richardson, A. Bradshaw, S. Jax, B. Wells, D. Sporles, S. Greene, R. Helu, D. Martin, J. Stewart
WR: P. Harvin, V. Jackson, M. Wallace, M. Colston, J. Jones (ATL), D. Thomas (DEN), D. Bryant, M. Austin, K. Britt, E. Decker, B. Lloyd, D. Bowe, P. Garcon, A. Brown.

Good trade or not??!?!!?!??! I figured I could let C.Johnson go because I still have A.Foster and A.Peterson.


CJ for Stafford/TRich/Charles + likely Austin/Colston is essentially the trade. Who is your new 4th keeper? That's what makes/breaks the trade.


who are 1.2's keepers? Is he going to go WR/RB or QB?

Ideally, you pick TRich at 1.1 and Stafford at 1.3.
_______________________________________

The Raiders new solar system to power up their offense: DC to AC.
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
I don't get a 4th Keeper now because I have to carry C.Johnson until the day of the draft. So my keepers are A. Foster, A. Peterson and A. Johnson.

1.2 Keepers are: D. McFadden, R. Matthews, A.J. Green and W.Welker....But his mind is made up, he's going RB with the 1.2 Pick, so he will get either Charles, T. Richardson or S. Jax depending on what I do.
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers
Megalodon
Posts: 10802
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007
Sand$: 42,808.66
So, 2.4 is the reward for substituting CJ with Charles/SJax/TRich?

annapolis_4 wrote:But his mind is made up, he's going RB with the 1.2 Pick, so he will get either Charles, T. Richardson or S. Jax depending on what I do.


In that case, you already know what I would suggest :roll: :lol:

Nice job of hedging your bets, guaranteeing Stafford and picking up an extra shot at a top 15 WR.
_______________________________________

The Raiders new solar system to power up their offense: DC to AC.
User avatar
Tiger Shark
Posts: 209
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006
Sand$: 558.00
Gotcha....Thanks for the input, I really appreciate it. :thumbright:
_______________________________________

QB: M.Stafford
RB: A.Foster, A.Peterson, R.Mathews, T.Richardson, B.Wells, R.Williams
WR: A.Johnson, J.Jones, D.Bryant, S.Holmes, K.Britt
TE: J.Finley
DEF: 49ers
K: D.Akers

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest