14 Team PPR - Trade for Rodgers

Post Reply  
User avatar
Leopard Shark
Posts: 102
Joined: Fri Oct 1, 2010
Sand$: 298.00
Just received a trade for Rodgers and very tempted. I'm a bit torn, I'm huge on Matthews this year. Should I feel confortable with Vick and pass on Mr. Consistant? Here is my current roster. Would you pull the trigger?

QB: Vick, Fitzpatrick
HB: Matthews, Murray, Blount, Starks, Ryan Williams
WR: Nicks, Antonio Brown, Moore, LaFell, M. Williams, Little

H2HO trades Ryan Mathews, SD RB to Leche Launchers
H2HO trades Hakeem Nicks, NYG WR to Leche Launchers
H2HO trades Mike Williams, TB WR to Leche Launchers
TLL trades Aaron Rodgers, GB QB to Hoes
TLL trades Marshawn Lynch, Sea RB to Hoes
TLL trades Mario Manningham, SF WR to
_______________________________________

10 Team H2H 0.5 PPR Standard
QB1: A. Rodgers | QB2: R. Grossman
HB1: D. McFadden | HB2: M. Turner | FLEX: R. Matthews
WR1: D. Bowe | WR2: R. Meachem | WR3: D. Henderson
TE: R. Gronkowski
Bench: J. Graham, S. Greene, K. Moreno, D. McCluster, D. Moore
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 17549
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2008
Sand$: 73,956.04
Hooker wrote:Just received a trade for Rodgers and very tempted. I'm a bit torn, I'm huge on Matthews this year. Should I feel confortable with Vick and pass on Mr. Consistant? Here is my current roster. Would you pull the trigger?

QB: Vick, Fitzpatrick
HB: Matthews, Murray, Blount, Starks, Ryan Williams
WR: Nicks, Antonio Brown, Moore, LaFell, M. Williams, Little

H2HO trades Ryan Mathews, SD RB to Leche Launchers
H2HO trades Hakeem Nicks, NYG WR to Leche Launchers
H2HO trades Mike Williams, TB WR to Leche Launchers
TLL trades Aaron Rodgers, GB QB to Hoes
TLL trades Marshawn Lynch, Sea RB to Hoes
TLL trades Mario Manningham, SF WR to


Need to know your starting requirments here, If it 2 rbs for a start, I think its a bad trade for you. The value is there, but you will have murray as your best back and after that you really have nothing. I like murray, but to have to count on him completely is a little much. I think you have to reject it even if you start 1 rbs.

You could try and trade vick fand one of your wrs or another rb. You would have to get that done before you do it.
User avatar
Whale Shark
Posts: 1290
Joined: Sat Jun 16, 2012
Sand$: 1,919.22
rugger48 wrote:Need to know your starting requirments here, If it 2 rbs for a start, I think its a bad trade for you. The value is there, but you will have murray as your best back and after that you really have nothing. I like murray, but to have to count on him completely is a little much. I think you have to reject it even if you start 1 rbs.

You could try and trade vick fand one of your wrs or another rb. You would have to get that done before you do it.


Interesting take. I'd be more nervous about WR's. Antonio Brown as a WR1 and who as a WR2?? If it was my team I would not do this trade. I would want a decent WR back instead of Manningham to consider it.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 7080
Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2006
Sand$: 6,007.56
I think Vick has a bounce back season, plus I like Matthews and Nicks too much to do this deal.

I'd say no.
_______________________________________

Sharks with Big Sticks and Stealing Home Keeper Baseball Leagues.

Hoping to do better then Hardwood Sharks basketball league after playing in my second straight championship game and getting embarrassed in the finals!
User avatar
Supreme Megalodon
Posts: 66670
Joined: Fri Dec 31, 2004
Sand$: 305,853.99
fishfry wrote:I think Vick has a bounce back season, plus I like Matthews and Nicks too much to do this deal.

I'd say no.


I agree on all counts.
_______________________________________

Image Image

Image
Chum
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2012
Sand$: 58.00
This is a bad trade for a few reasons.
1. I think that Starks has potential for you this year, and if that is the case, he will be taking away throwing TDs that you would be getting from Rodgers.
2. Lynch is a beast, however, he doesn't catch many balls, and he did just get paid.
3. I don't like your WR dept. Nicks is your number one, after him I think you have some potential sleepers in Little and Moore, but if they don't pan out you will be in trouble. Manningham probably wont have a a huge year, and at best he will be a flex option for you.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 2486
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009
Sand$: 27,821.28
I'd reject this.
_______________________________________

Image

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest