Donttellmywife wrote:My point is - Luck is a guarantee
The QB position has the highest payoff fantasy wise over a longer period of time. Look at Rodgers, Brady, Brees, now add Newton to the mix.
I'm obviously going to wait to see where Richardson goes but at this point it's still Luck for me.
Richardson is not a lock at all. He's a poor man's AP and hasn't even proven he can carry the load for multiple seasons in a row.
He sat behind Ingram for 3 years.
Also, my league is 1 pt PPR and Richardson can't catch.
Richardson is also coming off minor knee surgery.
I think you are over valuing Richardson right now.
hes the consensus #1 overall in all dynasty rookie drafts. I mean your bringing up his MINOR knee surgery, but yet your ready to trade the qb you do have for a guy who has had an acl and many say cant stay health with a full workload. Your just trying to find reasons to not draft him.
we are not overvaluing richardson, your just overvalueing qbs in general. Ill take richardson all day and everyday before I take a qb. Richardson cant catch? really thats news to me.
last time, you have an adeqaute qb right now, you take luck it will 2-3 years before it pays off for him to help your sqaud better than rivers is now. By that time charles will have been in the league 6 years and you will most likly be looking to replace him. Are you really going to go through all this to maybe get a qb who might throw for a couple TDS more than rivers is now?