Chum
Posts: 41
Joined: Tue Aug 4, 2009
Sand$: 179.90
Andre Johnson or Nicks this year? I drafted AJ with the 1st pick in the 3rd round and am having second thoughts. Being offered a straight up trade for Nicks.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9930
Joined: Tue Aug 28, 2007
Sand$: 21,569.64
I'll take AJ over Nicks. Both come with their own injury risks, but AJs ceiling is higher IMO.
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 14797
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2003
Sand$: 37,959.60
Johnson, but Nicks is a very good receiver.
_______________________________________

"If you can't spot the sucker in your first half hour at the table, then you are the sucker."
-Mike McD, Rounders
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 11750
Joined: Sun Nov 7, 2004
Sand$: 53,593.04
You should be having second thoughts. AJ can't be trusted for one second. AJ does have more talent and a lil more ceiling... But Nicks will play more games.
_______________________________________

Image Image
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 1738
Joined: Tue Sep 6, 2011
Sand$: 2,530.18
I think this would be a good poll question. I think arguments can truly be made for both sides and we'll only know the right answer after all is said and done. My vote is for Nicks only because I know a little more about what's in store and what to expect.
_______________________________________

Bottom-Dweller League 34 10-3 Lost in Finals
QB Stafford, Rivers
RB L Bell, L Murray, Gio, Denard
WR Wallace, G Tate, Martavis, Vjax
TE Julius, Fleener
K Barth
DEF Rams

Griffmo wrote:the allure of the unknown potential vs the available mediocrity
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 4306
Joined: Thu Sep 25, 2003
Sand$: 10,263.68
CRIPPLE FIGHT!

I would give the nod to Nicks over AJ if only for the fact that the Giants will be more prone to air it out than the Texans will...and that Nicks will probably be on the field more. :P
_______________________________________

SCS Wolfpack

Luck, Winston
Johnson (AZ), L. Murray, Stewart, Ivory, Peterson (I/R)
T. Williams, R. Matthews, Cobb, Gabriel
Graham, Doyle
Bailey, Zuerlein
Chargers, Bears

12-team / .5PPR / 1QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 Flex, 1 K, 1 DST
Blue Shark
Posts: 470
Joined: Tue Sep 6, 2011
Sand$: 1,196.34
I too have Nicks over AJ. Nicks will play more games, and is in a better offense for passing. AJ is past his prime.
_______________________________________

2013 Blue Shark League Champion
2012 Tiger Shark League Champion
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 7905
Joined: Sun Sep 9, 2007
Sand$: 2,267.22
(This is assuming both play a full season, because both aren't the picture of health)

Andre in PPR. He has higher upside due to his receptions (100+) and yardage (1400+). Nicks has the advantage in TD's, but not enough to overcome what I see as a 15-20 receptions and 150-200 yardage difference.

I have Andre as my #3 WR.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 1738
Joined: Tue Sep 6, 2011
Sand$: 2,530.18
zodiak wrote:(This is assuming both play a full season, because both aren't the picture of health)

Andre in PPR. He has higher upside due to his receptions (100+) and yardage (1400+). Nicks has the advantage in TD's, but not enough to overcome what I see as a 15-20 receptions and 150-200 yardage difference.

I have Andre as my #3 WR.

This also does assume everything goes back to the way it was (reasonable but not guaranteed). Last year Schaub averaged 29-30 attempts a game. Overall, the team (factoring in Schaub), averaged just over 29 a game. In 2010, they averaged 36 a game. In 2009, it was 37 a game. They could have switched gears because AJ was out or to further feature their strong run-game (taking advantage of strengths).

My guess is somewhere in the middle, so maybe 32-33 times a game this year? That's a 10% decline overall. So to be crude, that adjustment would put AJ (using 09-10 years prorated) at 93-1383-8. Nicks's avg the last 2 years prorated (including the playoff games) would be about 92-1344-11.

or one could prorate AJ's 1st 3 and 2 playoffs....and get 109-1654-10 :D

On our next episode of Fun With Numbers...
_______________________________________

Bottom-Dweller League 34 10-3 Lost in Finals
QB Stafford, Rivers
RB L Bell, L Murray, Gio, Denard
WR Wallace, G Tate, Martavis, Vjax
TE Julius, Fleener
K Barth
DEF Rams

Griffmo wrote:the allure of the unknown potential vs the available mediocrity
User avatar
Whale Shark
Posts: 1174
Joined: Tue Sep 1, 2009
Sand$: 2,007.90
I like Aj, however will concede that H-town will pass less but he's supreme talent-with that said, i drafted him and plan on trading him based off his name before the season gets deep
User avatar
Supreme Megalodon
Posts: 36296
Joined: Tue Sep 6, 2005
Sand$: 147,620.24
AJ for me



then pick up Jean late to bench and cover in deeper leagues
_______________________________________

"This whole world would be successful if everybody stopped quitting." - Evander Holyfield
HammerHead Shark
Posts: 859
Joined: Mon Oct 4, 2010
Sand$: 1,948.44
Going Nicks and its bc I have him

Also, he'll play more games. Don't trust AJ to stay healthy for as many games. Both are a bit injury prone, however. I'll go with the man playing more

But I would get Aj too, if I had a chance to get him. I just prefer Nicks
_______________________________________

QB- Wilson, Alex
HB- Gore, Hyde, DMC, Martin, Spiller
Wr- AJ, wallace, beasley, lockett, enunwa
Te- Graham, cook
Taxi, Cobb, turbin,
perriman, Goff
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 2123
Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2010
Sand$: 5,046.74
Nicks
Nicks Nicks
and Nicks
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 7905
Joined: Sun Sep 9, 2007
Sand$: 2,267.22
FantasyTom wrote:
zodiak wrote:(This is assuming both play a full season, because both aren't the picture of health)

Andre in PPR. He has higher upside due to his receptions (100+) and yardage (1400+). Nicks has the advantage in TD's, but not enough to overcome what I see as a 15-20 receptions and 150-200 yardage difference.

I have Andre as my #3 WR.

This also does assume everything goes back to the way it was (reasonable but not guaranteed). Last year Schaub averaged 29-30 attempts a game. Overall, the team (factoring in Schaub), averaged just over 29 a game. In 2010, they averaged 36 a game. In 2009, it was 37 a game. They could have switched gears because AJ was out or to further feature their strong run-game (taking advantage of strengths).

My guess is somewhere in the middle, so maybe 32-33 times a game this year? That's a 10% decline overall. So to be crude, that adjustment would put AJ (using 09-10 years prorated) at 93-1383-8. Nicks's avg the last 2 years prorated (including the playoff games) would be about 92-1344-11.

or one could prorate AJ's 1st 3 and 2 playoffs....and get 109-1654-10 :D

On our next episode of Fun With Numbers...

In the 3 games both Schaub and AJ were healthy in 2012, AJ averaged 10.7 targets of Schaub's 30.7 attempts per game. That's still over 170 targets when extrapolated, roughly the same amount he had in 2010 when extrapolated (169.8).

With a healthy AJ/Schaub the past two years they're averaging:
2010: 603 attempts (170 to AJ)
2011: 491 attempts (171 to AJ)

AJ is the #1 target and regardless of the amount of throwing will get his targets.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 1738
Joined: Tue Sep 6, 2011
Sand$: 2,530.18
zodiak wrote:
FantasyTom wrote:
zodiak wrote:(This is assuming both play a full season, because both aren't the picture of health)

Andre in PPR. He has higher upside due to his receptions (100+) and yardage (1400+). Nicks has the advantage in TD's, but not enough to overcome what I see as a 15-20 receptions and 150-200 yardage difference.

I have Andre as my #3 WR.

This also does assume everything goes back to the way it was (reasonable but not guaranteed). Last year Schaub averaged 29-30 attempts a game. Overall, the team (factoring in Schaub), averaged just over 29 a game. In 2010, they averaged 36 a game. In 2009, it was 37 a game. They could have switched gears because AJ was out or to further feature their strong run-game (taking advantage of strengths).

My guess is somewhere in the middle, so maybe 32-33 times a game this year? That's a 10% decline overall. So to be crude, that adjustment would put AJ (using 09-10 years prorated) at 93-1383-8. Nicks's avg the last 2 years prorated (including the playoff games) would be about 92-1344-11.

or one could prorate AJ's 1st 3 and 2 playoffs....and get 109-1654-10 :D

On our next episode of Fun With Numbers...

In the 3 games both Schaub and AJ were healthy in 2012, AJ averaged 10.7 targets of Schaub's 30.7 attempts per game. That's still over 170 targets when extrapolated, roughly the same amount he had in 2010 when extrapolated (169.8).

With a healthy AJ/Schaub the past two years they're averaging:
2010: 603 attempts (170 to AJ)
2011: 491 attempts (171 to AJ)

AJ is the #1 target and regardless of the amount of throwing will get his targets.

You took all the fun out of Fun With Numbers [-X
_______________________________________

Bottom-Dweller League 34 10-3 Lost in Finals
QB Stafford, Rivers
RB L Bell, L Murray, Gio, Denard
WR Wallace, G Tate, Martavis, Vjax
TE Julius, Fleener
K Barth
DEF Rams

Griffmo wrote:the allure of the unknown potential vs the available mediocrity

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest