Does anyone know of a site that offers this as a scoring option?
I remember hearing a while back someone stating that this is actually the best way reward players who are actually 'better', the 'go to guys' that coaches and QBs trust. The basic concept is this. Compared to PPR, who is more valuable, the scat back who catches an 11 yard dump off when it's 3rd and 14 or the grinder who gets 3 yards on 3rd and 2? Compared to Standard, if a guy with one touch scores a TD, 6 points is fine, but what about the TE who caught 3 passes on the drive to keep the chains moving during a 2 minute drill?
I think this options would reward the 'grizzled old vets' and sometimes the guy we hear in the scenario that 'they're a better real world option than a fantasy option'. Mostly I think it would see the outliers removed from top ten status.
A quick scan of 2017 (if I have the stats right) would show a few interesting things. For the most part the stars are right where they belong, but a few things that stood out to me in terms of this one stat:
- Keenan Allen would be #1 (followed by A.Brown, M.Thomas, D. Hopkins, J.Jones, L.Fitzgerald, J.Landry, A.Thielen, and A.Green ... in other words, the guys we all know are better players).
- Some guys seem to get bumped up a bit (M.Evans, M.Sanu, M.Goodwin) while some guys back down a bit (T.Hill, G.Tate, M.Jones).
The real place, though, where I think it might matter is in the RBs:
-It really helps (J.Howard, A.Collins, F.Gore) all in the top 10 in getting 1st downs (also M.Lynch, C.Anderson, J.Stewart do a little better) all in top 20.
-It really brings back to earth (Du.Johnson/only 36th) (A.Kamara/21st) (C.McCaffrey/48th).
I suppose the counter arguments will point out that the big play guys will make it up in yardage and TDs, which is fine, but I get the sense that on a game to game basis this will even things out better and make less fantasy games be settled by that one big play or the fact that a team was trailing big and went to certain guys only.
In any event, my league would like to try this option if it exists. Any thoughts?