Let them both walk. Sign mid range free range FA tackle and draft one early. Sorry, but Starks is not worth the money for an ok tackle at best. He is inconsistant and not worth sinking money into. I actually did not think there was a big drop off, between him and Essex when he filled in. He would be extemely cheap also. Smith is hurt to much anymore and not the risk unless you could get him dirt cheap which will not happen. I think the only way to rebuild this thing is the draft and Hopefully they can find a Hartwig type guy to fill in for a year or two if needed. Gees, and this is not getting into talking about Colon and the other side.