H2H points league
9 man offense (2-9 and DH), 7 man pitching staff SP, 2 RP) in a weekly lineup.
auction league, 0-10 keepers.
no term limits on keepers, but their prices get a $5 bump every season.
Team A gets:
Martin Perez - $1
Andrew Cashner - $1
Wilin Rosario - $1
Norichika Aoki - $1
Team B gets:
James Shields - $16
Team A has no shot at the playoffs, Team B is virtually assured of a playoff spot.
For team B, all 4 players being given up are bench guys most weeks. For team A, all 4 would be likely keeper options.
Does this seem reasonable for both sides?