Great White Shark
Posts: 8171
Joined: Wed Sep 4, 2002
Sand$: 4,724.37
und2006 wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:
StoneCutter wrote:I'm not saying this because I'm in second place, but I'm not seeing how this is much different than the chapter 6 bonus targeted penalty and not wanting to penalize someone for making good choices. Maybe I'm just not seeing the big picture.


The chapter 6 penalty target had no chance to avoid or mitigate the penalty. It was completely unilateral and why it was done away with. While the swap here is unilateral in the sense that the bump recipient can not stop it from happening, there are ways (with some risk) to start out near the top and still end up near the top, depending on how well you can anticipate the answers and behavior of your fellow participants. There is madness to the method...

It is also impossible to successfully gang up on the leaders in this for collective gain.


There is also nothing to gain for the leader whatsoever in this "challenge". I agree with O-Nut here... not a fan of this challenge.


Image

Approves of this challenge!
_______________________________________

Image


What women really want is security. I know because every time I approach a woman at a bar, that is what she starts screaming.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
Update: 19 replies received for round 1 of challenge 10. 7 to go. (c2o, Elmagister, endzoneview, OilersNut, SonOfDad, Third and Long, und2006)

I'll solicit proxy answers for any nonresponders starting around noon (EST) on Friday so I can hopefully post the results of round 1 and leave you all with round 2 on deck.
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
Megalodon
Posts: 24934
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2002
Sand$: 12,546.50
und2006 wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:
StoneCutter wrote:I'm not saying this because I'm in second place, but I'm not seeing how this is much different than the chapter 6 bonus targeted penalty and not wanting to penalize someone for making good choices. Maybe I'm just not seeing the big picture.


The chapter 6 penalty target had no chance to avoid or mitigate the penalty. It was completely unilateral and why it was done away with. While the swap here is unilateral in the sense that the bump recipient can not stop it from happening, there are ways (with some risk) to start out near the top and still end up near the top, depending on how well you can anticipate the answers and behavior of your fellow participants. There is madness to the method...

It is also impossible to successfully gang up on the leaders in this for collective gain.


There is also nothing to gain for the leader whatsoever in this "challenge". I agree with O-Nut here... not a fan of this challenge.



Image

Use it wisely!
User avatar
Megalodon
Posts: 17879
Joined: Thu Oct 19, 2006
Sand$: 38,038.16
ATL Souljah Boy wrote:
und2006 wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:
StoneCutter wrote:I'm not saying this because I'm in second place, but I'm not seeing how this is much different than the chapter 6 bonus targeted penalty and not wanting to penalize someone for making good choices. Maybe I'm just not seeing the big picture.


The chapter 6 penalty target had no chance to avoid or mitigate the penalty. It was completely unilateral and why it was done away with. While the swap here is unilateral in the sense that the bump recipient can not stop it from happening, there are ways (with some risk) to start out near the top and still end up near the top, depending on how well you can anticipate the answers and behavior of your fellow participants. There is madness to the method...

It is also impossible to successfully gang up on the leaders in this for collective gain.


There is also nothing to gain for the leader whatsoever in this "challenge". I agree with O-Nut here... not a fan of this challenge.



Image

Use it wisely!


Legends of the hidden temple ftw.

I remember that show fondly.
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
3 replies to go for challenge 10, round 1. And if anybody wants to revise their round 1 answers based upon the sand prize distribution listed in the game thread now, they have until noon today. Bear in mind those prizes are only given out based upon the standings after round 3 is complete.
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
Barring a miracle in the next couple of hours, looks like round 1 results are not going to be posted for awhile. I can't accept proxy replies for the tie-breaker, so hopefully the final 3 will get complete and correct answers in by the time I get back. (it also complicates things that 2 of the final 3 have the same proxy person selected) I'll check back in around 8 or 8:30, but that will be the last of my internet access for a week.
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
Megalodon
Posts: 21014
Joined: Sat Oct 18, 2003
Sand$: 19,257.90
DropkickFluties wrote:Barring a miracle in the next couple of hours, looks like round 1 results are not going to be posted for awhile. I can't accept proxy replies for the tie-breaker, so hopefully the final 3 will get complete and correct answers in by the time I get back. (it also complicates things that 2 of the final 3 have the same proxy person selected) I'll check back in around 8 or 8:30, but that will be the last of my internet access for a week.


No worries - still lots of offseason to go 8)
_______________________________________

Image
Megalodon
Posts: 11543
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2003
Sand$: 34,940.18
DropkickFluties wrote:Barring a miracle in the next couple of hours, looks like round 1 results are not going to be posted for awhile. I can't accept proxy replies for the tie-breaker, so hopefully the final 3 will get complete and correct answers in by the time I get back. (it also complicates things that 2 of the final 3 have the same proxy person selected) I'll check back in around 8 or 8:30, but that will be the last of my internet access for a week.

If I missed it, I apologize but where are you going for vacation?

Have a great time. :thumbright:
_______________________________________

Help me hurt myself. If I make my $1500 goal, I'll ride 100 miles, instead of 75, on the 1st day of the Bike MS: Colonial Crossroads 2018 ride for a total of 175 miles over the 2 days.
https://secure.nationalmssociety.org/si ... XY_TYPE=20
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
dmcduke wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:Barring a miracle in the next couple of hours, looks like round 1 results are not going to be posted for awhile. I can't accept proxy replies for the tie-breaker, so hopefully the final 3 will get complete and correct answers in by the time I get back. (it also complicates things that 2 of the final 3 have the same proxy person selected) I'll check back in around 8 or 8:30, but that will be the last of my internet access for a week.

If I missed it, I apologize but where are you going for vacation?

Have a great time. :thumbright:


Sneaking in for a sec before we head to the airport to catch a flight to a place billed as the happiest place on earth even though it's populated with snot-nosed crying brats, mammoth cows riding in scooters because they're too lazy to walk, and food prices that would wipe out most 3rd world country populations. It is going to be glorious!
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
Megalodon
Posts: 11543
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2003
Sand$: 34,940.18
DropkickFluties wrote:
dmcduke wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:Barring a miracle in the next couple of hours, looks like round 1 results are not going to be posted for awhile. I can't accept proxy replies for the tie-breaker, so hopefully the final 3 will get complete and correct answers in by the time I get back. (it also complicates things that 2 of the final 3 have the same proxy person selected) I'll check back in around 8 or 8:30, but that will be the last of my internet access for a week.

If I missed it, I apologize but where are you going for vacation?

Have a great time. :thumbright:


Sneaking in for a sec before we head to the airport to catch a flight to a place billed as the happiest place on earth even though it's populated with snot-nosed crying brats, mammoth cows riding in scooters because they're too lazy to walk, and food prices that would wipe out most 3rd world country populations. It is going to be glorious!

:lol: :lol: :lol:
Been there, done that. Twice :shock:
_______________________________________

Help me hurt myself. If I make my $1500 goal, I'll ride 100 miles, instead of 75, on the 1st day of the Bike MS: Colonial Crossroads 2018 ride for a total of 175 miles over the 2 days.
https://secure.nationalmssociety.org/si ... XY_TYPE=20
Great White Shark
Posts: 2219
Joined: Thu Jul 29, 2010
Sand$: 2,913.06
und2006 wrote:
ATL Souljah Boy wrote:
und2006 wrote:
DropkickFluties wrote:
StoneCutter wrote:I'm not saying this because I'm in second place, but I'm not seeing how this is much different than the chapter 6 bonus targeted penalty and not wanting to penalize someone for making good choices. Maybe I'm just not seeing the big picture.


The chapter 6 penalty target had no chance to avoid or mitigate the penalty. It was completely unilateral and why it was done away with. While the swap here is unilateral in the sense that the bump recipient can not stop it from happening, there are ways (with some risk) to start out near the top and still end up near the top, depending on how well you can anticipate the answers and behavior of your fellow participants. There is madness to the method...

It is also impossible to successfully gang up on the leaders in this for collective gain.


There is also nothing to gain for the leader whatsoever in this "challenge". I agree with O-Nut here... not a fan of this challenge.



Image

Use it wisely!


Legends of the hidden temple ftw.

I remember that show fondly.



Blue Barracudas all the way!
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
All right, I'm back. Will be off my feet most of the weekend I hope, and catching up on a week's worth of missed internet.

Challenge 10, round 1 still needs replies from SonOfDad and und2006. I'll be sending them PM's right after this post. Really don't want to do proxies because the tiebreaker answer is still needed. But I'll allow their proxies to answer for them on Monday at some point if I haven't heard back.
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
Great White Shark
Posts: 9848
Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006
Sand$: 20,188.36
Welcome back! Hope that big frackin rat was good to everyone
User avatar
Great White Shark
Posts: 9311
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2009
Sand$: 11,206.26
It was good, but I am completely Disneyed out now. 14-hour days on my feet and early wakeups... I need a vacation from the vacation. This was my 2nd trip ever and I only expect to go once more in my life when my niece and nephew make their first trip. Slight system shock going from mid-80's every day to low 40's now. Got nearly 700 pictures/videos to process too. My intolerance for whiny kids and fatties is at an all-time high, but time heals all wounds. :) And totally stoked that our free dining plan saved us at least $800.
_______________________________________

Veritas Odium Parit
Megalodon
Posts: 18575
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2009
Sand$: 53,960.40
Glad you had a good time DropkickFluties and didn't get caught murdering any kids or fatties.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 1 guest